What Are You Allowed to Do? Free Speech, Public Defenders & Florida Man | S2,E7
Transcript
Jake Rigney: 00:15
It’s Friday. It’s not the afternoon, but if any news between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. breaks, we weren’t going to cover it anyway. So here we go. We’ve locked the doors because I’m trying to keep Jensen Huang away from all the women in my life, and also because it’s time for another edition of our bi-weekly podcast, Tales from the Brown Desk. I’m Jake Rigney of Rigney Law LLC. With me as usual is my law partner, wife, and the only reason that I’m not single, Kassi Rigney. With this is our host, manager, editor, co-producer, topic selector, Florida Man monitor, email screener, clock switch point award giver, and Dungeons and Dragons noob. Teri Muehlhausen. Friendly reminder, Tales from the Brown Desk is a free-flowing conversation involving two foul-mouthed attorneys. It may include graphic descriptions of sexual activity, violence, and Jensen Huang 63-year-old naughty bits. At least I hope they are 63 years old. You get a Naughty Bits transplant to get like a younger dude’s junk squat in? If so, should CEOs have to disclose that to their board so they can consider whether that will impact the CEO’s decision? Uh because those decisions could possibly tank the entire economy. Questions that will never be answered, most likely. Welcome to Late Stage Capitalism, where our entire retirement accounts are at the whims of what an old dude likes to do with Asian spies. Jesus. This podcast may not be suitable for Americans, 63-year-old fuckboys, Chinese honey traps, and your 401k. Here’s Teri.
Teri Muehlhausen: 02:11
Hi everyone. Hi Jake. How are you today?
Jake Rigney: 02:14
Hi, Teri. I am in a stellar mood, in case you can’t tell from how I wrote the script today, and it’s gonna get darker. So just get ready.
Teri Muehlhausen: 02:22
I’m I’m ready. Hi Kassi, how are you?
Kassi Rigney: 02:25
Hi Teri, I’m well. Good. Thanks.
Jake Rigney: 02:28
Same thing every week, no matter what’s going on. Economy in shambles, Kassi. Hi Teri, I’m well. At least she’s predictable. Like liberals win stunning election results. Hi, Kassi. How are you? Hi Teri, I’m well. Just doesn’t matter.
Kassi Rigney: 02:46
Well, my feelings don’t matter.
Jake Rigney: 02:52
Just a walking perfect example of American stoicism in the 21st century, which is exactly what she’s going for, by the way.
Teri Muehlhausen: 02:59
Nice. Okay, so today we’re going to talk about a recent Indiana Court of Appeals decision. We’ll also talk about public defenders, the right to represent yourself, and what happens when someone decides they don’t need an attorney. And that’s the theme of today’s show. What are you allowed to do? And where does the law draw that line? Also on today’s docket is the Glock switch and Florida Man. Are you two ready?
Kassi Rigney: 03:29
It’s ready as I’m gonna be.
Jake Rigney: 03:30
I was promised a shorter podcast, Teri. That does not sound that sounds just as long.
Teri Muehlhausen: 03:37
It does it does, doesn’t it? So it’s the amount of questions I have with these topics. So let’s hope I can I could do this.
Jake Rigney: 03:45
All right. Well, let’s let’s see how it goes.
Teri Muehlhausen: 03:47
I know. I’m in the spotlight now. Okay, so let’s start with that Indiana Court of Appeals decision. It’s a case that involves a man named Craig Hindra and a speech that he gave at a city council meeting in Linton, Indiana. Are you too familiar with this case?
Kassi Rigney: 04:07
After I read it.
Teri Muehlhausen: 04:08
That’s great.
Jake Rigney: 04:10
This is the the opening test where she figures out how far she’s gonna have to carry us through this discussion. Um the answer to your question, Teri, is you gave us a 25-page appellate opinion to read. I read the first 18 pages of it very closely, and the last six or seven pages I skimmed.
Teri Muehlhausen: 04:31
I think that’ll give you the gist.
Jake Rigney: 04:33
I knew how the last topic was gonna go. I didn’t feel like I needed to read it. It was their worst argument, so it was easy to predict.
Teri Muehlhausen: 04:41
Would either of you care to tell the listeners about this case?
Jake Rigney: 04:46
Uh do you want to do it or do you want me to?
Kassi Rigney: 04:48
That’s fine. I’ll I’ll give my gist and you’ll clean it up.
Jake Rigney: 04:51
Go for it.
Kassi Rigney: 04:52
Uh so uh what’s his name, Mr. Hendry. Hendry uh was lounging at his home. The police arrived in an attempt to uh serve an arrest warrant. It appears he did not answer the door. They sat outside and waited for a warrant to be granted to enter the house and make the arrest. When they reapproached the house, I believe he answered the door and he was the arrest warrant was served. He was taken into custody without issue. However, down the road, he complains to the police chief, saying that the police kicked in his door illegally and then basically arrested him, held him illegally in jail. He went to a city council meeting and basically repeated those specific claims, but also called them terrorists and the other general term, some other tax whores or something.
Jake Rigney: 05:52
Tax leeches.
Kassi Rigney: 05:53
Tax leeches. Um he made some general uh commentary about the government officials, but the specific complaints were um kicking in the door without authorization, kidnapping him, and kidnapping him. Um he is later charged with a crime of false informing, and he files a dismissal saying the it’s a violation of his free speech rights, and the law was written too broadly. He went to trial and lost, he went, took the case up on appeal and lost.
Jake Rigney: 06:31
Yeah, it’s a there’s this weird inequality in Indiana law that surprises almost everyone when I explain it to them.
Teri Muehlhausen: 06:39
What’s that?
Jake Rigney: 06:40
The police can lie to you, and in almost every circumstance, there’s nothing wrong with that. But if you lie to the police, you are committing a misdemeanor. Unless it just basically has no impact on their investigation.
Teri Muehlhausen: 06:56
So is that like the for the better good argument to stop the crime and protect the society is why there’s a double standard?
Jake Rigney: 07:05
I would hesitate to offer a guess as to why there’s a double standard, because I don’t think it’s appropriate for there to be a double standard, right? I I think that either it if if the police can lie to people, people should be allowed to lie to the police. Not because it’s the First Amendment necessarily, just because if if they get to use that tactic on us, then I think we ought to be able to use that tactic on them. Um, just sort of fairness, right? But that’s not the claim he made. Um he claimed that it violated his First Amendment rights and that the First Amendment protects his ability to lie um about what what happened to him because they did not, in fact, kick his door in, or at least it doesn’t appear so. There were a couple of like weird little mentions in the Court of Appeals opinion that suggested that there might have been some confusion about whether it was that specific event as opposed to some other time that maybe wasn’t captured on body camera footage. Um but ultimately the jury determined that he did lie. Um that he said he had his the door to his home kicked in when there was apparently no evidence of that. They then went on to determine that the First Amendment does not apply to that particular type of lie. Exaggerations, rhetorical flourishes like it are allowed, but just an outright misstatement of a specific fact that occurred is not protected by either the First Amendment or Indiana’s Free Expression Clause, which are different constitutional provisions, but neither protected him.
Teri Muehlhausen: 09:00
Now he was convicted of a crime based on those statements that he made at that city council meeting. He recorded that little speech and he published it on his YouTube channel and it is still there. Are there any issues with it still being there? A crime on YouTube?
Jake Rigney: 09:20
Well, the double jeopardy clause would attach. Right? So in theory, leaving a post up that is a lie, like i is a new crime, I guess, like every I don’t know, if you want to look at every day or something like that. But he’s already been convicted of telling this lie. Um it’s unlikely that he could be convicted again for telling the same lie because that would be punishing him twice for essentially the same conduct. It sort of depends on what you mean by is there any issue with like should people post lies and leave them up on their YouTube page? No, they shouldn’t. That reminds me that I had a I I misspoke in our podcast two weeks ago um about some minor issue where I meant to say would and said wouldn’t instead or the reverse of that or something.
Teri Muehlhausen: 10:11
Yeah, I know where you’re talking about.
Jake Rigney: 10:13
Yeah. Yeah. Uh I I noticed it when I listened to the podcast later.
Speaker 5: 10:16
So it was a death penalty thing.
Jake Rigney: 10:18
Yep, yep. So uh if if you go back and listen to that one and you find that I made some mistake uh or that something sounded weird and didn’t make sense, it was an error. I wasn’t lying. Um But um yeah, I mean typically you shouldn’t just leave lies up out there in the world, right? So that’s an issue. But I don’t think he’s looking at any other criminal uh issues related to that because he’s already been punished for it.
Teri Muehlhausen: 10:47
Um is sharing the video with our listeners a crime? A clip.
Jake Rigney: 10:58
I think it’s the I think it depends on the context in which we share it and how we share it, right? So if we post it without any context provided, um, in such a way that you know it would lead people to believe that um we were saying Linton County did this, right? We could potentially be sued for libel or defamation. We wouldn’t be committing a crime because we are not publishing it to a law enforcement agency or a law enforcement officer, right? But we might get sued. But if we posted it within context, right, as this is what he said, and this is why he got in trouble for saying this particular thing. Where it’s clear or should be clear to the viewer that we are not saying Linton did this, we are explaining why Craig Hendry got in trouble for saying this, and this is what he actually said. In that context, if we fill it out correctly, follow normal journalistic procedure for that by making it very clear what it is, then it’s highly unlikely we would get in trouble for that. Just like the Court of Appeals doesn’t get in trouble for publishing quotes of what he said, right? They’re not telling you what he said because they believe it, they’re telling you what he said so that you know what he said.
Teri Muehlhausen: 12:22
Do you care to hear a minute of his clip where he makes these accusations?
Kassi Rigney: 12:27
So I don’t, but I mean, if you want to play us two of ours for some reason.
Teri Muehlhausen: 12:33
The thing that caught me is like first when you’re reading this and you’re hearing about this guy going to a city council meeting, I picture like this irate guy in there yelling at these people, but that’s not what he was. He was like dressed nice and talking very calmly.
Kassi Rigney: 12:49
Well, frankly, that makes his lies more he should be more culpable if he’s just a raging tyrant, might be more likely to disbelieve him. Right. Um, but I mean, this comes down to I mean, this is not an emotional process, and it comes down to what he said, and he made specific allegations that could directly be disproved, sound at least according to the record.
Teri Muehlhausen: 13:13
Yeah. Well, in this video, he says that the police were there to serve that warrant. True. Because of a year earlier, he decided to sell cannabis, a plant that grows out of the ground, he says, to consenting adults. And that should not be a reason for someone to get their door broke down.
Jake Rigney: 13:36
Incorrect.
Kassi Rigney: 13:38
Well, he was being a drug dealer, and you can state it whatever way you want. But I mean, he was breaking the law, he was knowingly breaking the law. He didn’t think that the police can serve a warrant on him when you’re breaking the law. I mean, this person is ridiculous.
Jake Rigney: 13:53
Heroin comes from a plant. And it grows out of the ground as well, and that doesn’t mean it’s okay to sell it to people just because it grows out of the ground. Cocaine comes from a plant that grows out of the ground. That does not make it okay to sell it to consenting adults. Why? Because it’s extraordinarily addictive and unhealthy.
Kassi Rigney: 14:16
In my opinion, this is a great example of uh confident ignorance. I can only imagine how many attorneys he tried to consult with who were telling him that he was wrong and he I don’t need attorneys. I just see right through this.
Teri Muehlhausen: 14:30
Uh another interesting part of this case is on appeal, the ACLU filed an amicus brief. Yeah. Supporting um Hendry. And why why would uh an organization like that file a brief?
Jake Rigney: 14:46
So this happens um somewhat regularly on high profile appeals cases. This one isn’t as high profile, and I’m a little bit surprised that the ACLU or the ICLU, whoever it was, got involved. Um, but the reason they got involved is because it does impact this civil liberty, right? The freedom of speech. And they were probably at least a little bit concerned that well see, but he wasn’t pro se on appeal. Um he had an attorney on appeal. Um, so they wouldn’t be concerned. I mean, I guess it’s possible they were just concerned that that attorney wouldn’t properly advocate the issue, you know, those particular issues. But um, you know, I I think most likely it just boiled down to them. It was a f a free speech case, and they don’t they think that it’s an opportunity for the court to change certain rules around free speech. And so they decided to spend some time trying to convince the court to maybe rework some of those rules. Um because there are a lot of rules about what is and isn’t free speech that are extraordinarily unclear from the texts of our constitution. Right? And the end result of that is that people often do not understand what is actually protected and what isn’t protected by free speech, right? They think that Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, that’s what the Constitution says, means that I can say whatever I want. But the Supreme Court, especially over the last hundred, hundred and fifteen years, has carved out huge chunks of speech that is not protected by the First Amendment. These include actual threats, demonstrably false factual statements, child pornography, um there are several others, fighting words, right? So um you cannot walk up to a cop and say you’re I’m trying to think of the most offensive possible thing. Um, you know, you’re yeah, you can’t insult his mother, essentially, or you know, I don’t know. Um think of the most offensive thing you can think of to say to a person, you’re not allowed to just walk up to somebody and say that and then say, Well, freedom of speech allows me to just say whatever I want. If you walk up to an African American person and say the N-word to their face, right? You call them the N-word. You cannot claim that you are allowed to do that because it’s free speech. Because that is a statement that is almost certainly likely to get you punched in the face, and everyone knows that. It’s not protected by the First Amendment. It got even more funky when the Supreme Court started acknowledging that some conduct counts as free speech, right? But then some doesn’t. And so then that made it even more complicated to the point where they, you know, they can say things like wearing a coat that has a message on the back is free speech. Um, but dancing naked at a gentleman’s club is maybe got a little bit of free speech protection, maybe, right? Um, and then flying a plane into the World Trade Center, which by the way, is very much expressive conduct.
Teri Muehlhausen: 18:20
Yeah, that’s free speech, right? Right. Yeah.
Jake Rigney: 18:22
Well, it’s not free speech, it’s it’s not protected by the First Amendment, but it is very much expressive conduct.
Teri Muehlhausen: 18:28
Yes, it is.
Jake Rigney: 18:30
When I used to teach this subject, I I kind of broke a couple of kids’ brains when I asked them about this, right? I was like, so we’ve talked about you know conduct as speech. Sometimes doing a thing is a statement, right? So um, what about flying your plane into the uh World Trade Center? Is that is that speech? And they’re like, well, no, that’s terrorism. And I’m like, I’m pretty sure they had a point. Yeah, and I’m pretty sure it was related to government.
Teri Muehlhausen: 18:59
Yeah, message sent.
Jake Rigney: 19:00
Right? But also not protected by the First Amendment because it’s an actual criminal attack, um, just like you know, bombing Fort Knox or attacking an airbase is not protected by first the First Amendment, even though it is conduct intended to express a viewpoint.
Teri Muehlhausen: 19:22
Now, does this decision change someone’s right to criticize the police?
Kassi Rigney: 19:28
No. I mean, I thought the opinion did a good job separating out, you know, an a developed opinion about, you know, an organization or particular position versus a specific allegation because it was very specific. They kicked in my door without a warrant. They kidnapped me, you know, without a warrant. These are specific allegations that have the ability to be determined whether they are true or false.
Jake Rigney: 19:56
Yeah. And and outright absolute falsity is not protected by the First Amendment. So I’m surprised. I’m surprised they spent so much time sort of explaining what is and isn’t allowed because they could have just said this is demonstrably false. Demonstrably false things are not protected by the First Amendment. Um there are several cases that kind of allow for errors that are not demonstrably false, right? Um one of the most famous First Amendment cases. See you you drugged me into First Amendment and you said it was going to be short. It’s it never is.
Teri Muehlhausen: 20:37
I have no idea.
Jake Rigney: 20:38
Um New York Times versus Sullivan. Right? Um The New York Times published an ad um that was sponsored by one of the many civil rights groups in the South, and it had some minor factual inaccuracies in it, right? It said I I don’t even remember the specifics anymore. It was something like they said that twelve twelve of theirs twelve of their people were arrested for no good reason when it was really only eight or something like that. You know what I mean? Like the numbers were wrong a little bit, or the amount of time that they were jailed was a little bit wrong. Um and what the Sullivan is actually the share of down in the small little county that was mistreating the African American people, right? And a lot of times what these small local government officials would do when big northern media got involved is they’d sue them. Right? Oh. It wasn’t it wasn’t twelve, it was only eight. That’s libel. I’m gonna sue you. And they would do that to try to keep these big northern newspapers from publicizing what the civil rights movement folks were doing. That’s what happened. Sullivan sued the New York Times over these minor really kind of irrelevant mistakes, and this the Supreme Court said, Well, you can’t do that. Um you have to prove When it’s something this important, like a political question, you have to prove a uh a higher level of fault than just accidental small errors. You have to know that it’s false or engage in reckless disregard for the truth or falsity of the statement. But this doesn’t fall into that because he knows it’s false. It’s demonstrably false.
Teri Muehlhausen: 22:26
So Hendry represented himself at trial. So let’s talk about that for a minute. When can somebody have an attorney? And what if they can’t afford an attorney?
Kassi Rigney: 22:38
Well, the it’s at any meaningful stage. I mean, if you’re you decide to give an interview to the police, you have a right to have an attorney present. Um, you have the right to have an attorney present at in court for you.
Teri Muehlhausen: 22:50
Does anyone charged with a crime have that right, or do like civil people?
Kassi Rigney: 22:55
The right to an attorney at no cost is exclusively a criminal right under criminal law.
Jake Rigney: 23:01
But you have the right to the attorney of your choosing in any legal proceeding. So they in an actual court proceeding, they can never tell you like you can’t bring a lawyer in here. But in civil proceedings, you don’t have the right to one for free.
Teri Muehlhausen: 23:16
And now how does someone qualify for a public defender?
Kassi Rigney: 23:21
Well, the j the judge on their case has to make a determination of indigency, so they need to determine that the person cannot actually afford an attorney, and then they would appoint one.
Jake Rigney: 23:34
Yeah, I’ve done that a bunch of times when I’ve filled in as a judge. What you do is you put them under oath and then you ask them a series of questions to figure out whether you think they can afford an attorney or not. There’s guidelines for what the poverty level is, and it depends on how many kids you have or how many people you sport and all that. The judge does a quick little math calculation or looks at a spreadsheet that’s been printed out for them and decides whether you qualify or not. In Marion County, a lot of times the judge kind of defaults to you qualify, although sometimes they still do reject folks. Um, in other counties, often they are a bit more stringent on those requirements, and they will often tell people no.
Teri Muehlhausen: 24:16
Is that because of budget restrictions?
Jake Rigney: 24:19
Well, I don’t know exactly why. I think it varies from judge to judge. Sometimes I think it’s because the court is paying the public defender, and so they don’t want to pay for someone who doesn’t truly need it. Um of them also, some judges I think are somewhat hostile to the idea of public defenders to begin with. Um, you know, it’s a relatively new development in American law. It was only in the 60s when we finally decided that everyone charged with a crime had to have a lawyer. Um Gideon versus Wainwright was the case. Um the whole thing was literally started because he he turned in a like single two-inch by four-inch piece of paper that said, I would like an attorney, please.
Teri Muehlhausen: 25:04
Nice.
Jake Rigney: 25:05
And that got all the way to the US Supreme Court. The US Supreme Court said, You should have given him a lawyer conviction. Conviction vacated. Not everyone thinks that that this is weird because a lot of these rights have been enshrined in the Constitution for a long time, right? Not everyone thinks that everyone should get a lawyer in a criminal case. Not everyone agrees with the court’s decision in Gideon versus Wainwright. Just like not everyone believes in the right to remain silent. Um, if you go and you look back through the legal jurisprudence on it, there are people who do advocate from time to time for us to abolish that right. And that at a trial the state should be allowed to call the defendant and make them explain their situation. And if they don’t, um then they look bad, right? Um there’s even I mean, there’s US Supreme Court jurisprudence where they sort of footnote articles where some people suggest we’d be just fine without that right. Of course, those people have never been charged with a crime.
Teri Muehlhausen: 26:16
Now one thing that’s crazy to me is if I got charged with a crime, I could represent myself without ever passing a bar exam. True. Like, like how smart is that? Like you guys go through a lot of training and education and like work to understand the ins and outs of there. So, like, why like why is that even my right that I can go and try to do your job?
Kassi Rigney: 26:42
I don’t know the history of that right. Um, Jake might, but I I mean I the the first question was is it a good idea? It’s not a good idea. I don’t think it’s in your best interest.
Jake Rigney: 26:53
Yeah, the case most commonly cited or is Feretta versus California. Um, and so lawyers often refer to people’s right to represent themselves as their Ferretta rights. Um and I think it’s it’s been a long time since I read the case law related to this issue or the theory behind it, but I think it has to do with the concept of government by the people and self-determination. Right? That if if you’re in a legal, you know, if if your legal situation it affects you, it doesn’t affect anyone else really. Even the lawyers don’t, you know, I’m they don’t get in trouble, right? Whether they win or they lose. So it only affects you. So you have the right, if you can’t find a lawyer to do what you want, then you can go try to do it yourself. Um and it’s just sort of this basic right of self-determination or self-direction of the legal issue. Um I I think is the point behind it. What were you gonna say, Cass?
Kassi Rigney: 28:05
Well, I I I think you moved on from it, but I was gonna make the point that um people think it’s a good idea or want to do it, but don’t think about how oftentimes lawyers who are charged with crimes hire lawyers and choose not to represent themselves. And that should be a real big indicator that, hey, maybe it’s not a great idea to represent yourself, even when you have a law degree.
Teri Muehlhausen: 28:28
Right.
Jake Rigney: 28:28
Yeah, I mean, it it is almost universally a bad idea. It did not work out for Mr. Hendry here either. But I will tell you, if you go and look, you will find some people, a few, who have successfully defended themselves without you know while representing themselves, either at trial or on appeal.
Kassi Rigney: 28:52
There’s one gentleman I heard about who I think he’s even a professor, maybe even at Harvard Law School, who had done his own appeal and got out and uh was actually able through reading to learn the skills to do the legal thinking and putting things together, but most people can’t develop those thinking the thinking skills on their own.
Teri Muehlhausen: 29:19
Right. He already started with a head start with his just understanding and education.
Jake Rigney: 29:25
This isn’t a real precise analogy, but it’s kind of like um trying to be an amateur astronomer. Right. So if you didn’t know anything about astronomy and you hadn’t been taught, you’d been taught almost nothing about astronomy, and you just sat on the earth and you just said, Okay, well, and now I’m gonna be an astronomer. Well, the first conclusion you would probably draw is that the sun goes around the earth, right? Because it goes up and down every day, right? It travels through our sky. Um, and so the theory, like you know, it that would make sense. It the sun looks like it goes around the earth, right? Um, it’s kind of flawless logic if all you think about is this is what I can see and this is what happens every day, right? But once we learn a bunch more facts about astronomy, including the moon and what it’s doing, and you know, other planets and what they’re doing and how they appear and disappear in our sky, it becomes abundantly clear that there is simply no way that the sun goes around the earth. The earth must go around the sun, it must be one of these planets like Mercury and Mars and Venus and Uranus and Neptune and all the rest, right? Because otherwise, these things would not appear in the sky the way they do. But if all you do is you look at the sun, well, then you’ve got a good argument. Or you think you do.
Teri Muehlhausen: 30:55
Yeah.
Jake Rigney: 30:56
But you really don’t.
Teri Muehlhausen: 30:57
Right. Now, if someone represents themselves at trial and they make a mistake and that causes them to lose, can they later use that mistake to get their conviction overturned?
Jake Rigney: 31:10
No.
Teri Muehlhausen: 31:10
Can they win their appeal?
Jake Rigney: 31:12
No, that is what’s called an invited error.
Teri Muehlhausen: 31:16
Invited error could because you should have known better.
Kassi Rigney: 31:20
You don’t get to represent yourself without a judge very clearly explaining to you you’re not a lawyer, you didn’t go to law school, you understand. If you do this, you are bound by all of the rules that a lawyer is and all the law. And just as you point, you want to go in there and shoot yourself in the foot, they’ll let you, and you’ll be stuck with it. And you won’t have anybody to blame but yourself.
Jake Rigney: 31:46
Yeah. So so if the trial court makes some error that you ask them to do or you failed to object to, you do not get to appeal later and say, like, well, look, look at this mistake that the judge made that I talked them into making.
Teri Muehlhausen: 32:01
No.
Jake Rigney: 32:02
Um, this should cause my thing to get overturned. They’ll say, Yeah, that was a mistake, but we’re not going to overturn it because of invited error.
Teri Muehlhausen: 32:10
All right. So I think we have established that representing yourself in court can be pretty risky. So we’re going to leave the courtroom because it’s time for something that requires a different kind of legal expertise, and that’s the Glock switch.
Jake Rigney: 32:28
Kassi’s
Kassi Rigney: 32:29
I know Kassi’s face.
Jake Rigney: 32:31
Oh, this bullshit again.
Kassi Rigney: 32:34
It’s the brown desk full auto question and answer round where the questions are quick, the answers better be good, and the rules are completely unreasonable. Today’s lock switch comes with a little twist. I have five questions and a handful of house rules. I’m gonna change these rules as we go, so don’t get too comfortable. I called on you guys catching on and
Jake Rigney: 33:01
Yeah.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:02
Yeah.
Jake Rigney: 33:02
This is the right move. We anytime you give lawyers a set of rules, we will immediately start trying to figure out how to game those rules to our benefit. So, yeah, switching them, switching them is the only reasonable way forward. We will still complain, right? Because then I will complain that my set of rules were harder than her set of rules.
Kassi Rigney: 33:24
Yeah.
Jake Rigney: 33:25
But whatever.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:26
Right.
Jake Rigney: 33:26
That’s fine. You also need to do an even number of questions so we both get the same number of turns, otherwise, I will complain about that.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:32
Oh, okay. Let’s see what I got.
Kassi Rigney: 33:34
You can go three times every time.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:37
All right. Remember, I’m making the rules, I don’t have to follow them.
Jake Rigney: 33:43
That sounds familiar. Didn’t we just talk about that a minute ago, right? Teri is the police in this situation.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:51
Exactly. I’m gonna really like take on this role.
Jake Rigney: 33:56
Well, please don’t uh bounce my head off a table.
Teri Muehlhausen: 33:59
I I won’t. Who’s up first?
Kassi Rigney: 34:01
Fine, I’ll go.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:02
Okay.
Jake Rigney: 34:03
Who’s the defending champion? Who won last week?
Kassi Rigney: 34:06
You did. Yeah.
Jake Rigney: 34:07
Okay. So I should go first because going first is a disadvantage in this game.
Kassi Rigney: 34:11
Okay.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:12
Okay. The first house rule is answers must include a rhyming component.
Jake Rigney: 34:20
Okay.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:21
Take cover. If you find a wallet full of cash, is keeping it a crime.
Jake Rigney: 34:30
Uh, it is not a crime you won’t do anytime.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:35
Nice. Yeah. Good job.
Jake Rigney: 34:38
I’m good at this.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:39
That was nice.
Jake Rigney: 34:40
I I desperately was like as soon as you said it had to rhyme, I was like, I’m gonna rap. Don’t rap. Don’t rap, Jake. Don’t rap.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:54
Mm, is that you?
Jake Rigney: 34:56
No. I am not.
Teri Muehlhausen: 34:58
Okay, Kassi, you up. The rule is: Answers must include a sound effect. Can the police search your trash after you put it out on the curb?
Kassi Rigney: 35:11
Yes.
Teri Muehlhausen: 35:14
That works.
Jake Rigney: 35:15
Don’t they? Isn’t there some rule about trash poles?
Kassi Rigney: 35:18
Yeah, they they have there are some rules about it, but they can. I mean, they it it’s not straight abandoned property, but I haven’t read a trash pull case in twelve years, so I don’t remember.
Jake Rigney: 35:29
Yeah, there that I remember there are some rules about it. It’s not just uh they can go rummaging through your trash.
Kassi Rigney: 35:35
They have to make some kind of connection. I don’t think it’s not like cops running plates while they’re on the street that they can just randomly walk up to trash and start going through it. There has to be some something. But like I said, I haven’t litigated a trash pull in over 10 years.
Jake Rigney: 35:53
Right. So so like if they’re investigating you for, you know, um welfare fraud or something like that. Um they it probably can’t go through your trash because there’s not likely to be a bunch of evidence of welfare fraud in your trash. Right. I think that’s what it is. It has to have some connection to the crime you’re investigating or something like that.
Kassi Rigney: 36:14
They have to have some rational basis to can make a connection. It’s not the same as uh it’s not as full-blown probable cause as a search warrant.
Jake Rigney: 36:25
Right. But if they think it’s a crack house, then they can search the trash because you’re likely to throw away the remnants of the stuff you used to make the crack.
Teri Muehlhausen: 36:34
Uh-huh. Okay. That was that was you, Kassi, right? Yeah. All right. So you’re up next. Okay. Next rule is answers must include the word opposite. Can the police fly a drone over your fenced backyard to see what’s happening in there without getting a search warrant?
Jake Rigney: 36:56
The opposite of yes is no, which is the answer in this case. They cannot use a drone to search your backyard if they couldn’t see your backyard or standing in a public space. Um, they’re not allowed to use drones to look into places, or they’re not even allowed to climb up onto your fence and look over it if they couldn’t see through it. Um they have to be in a public place doing what a person would normally be allowed to do in order to um say that they saw something in plain view later.
Kassi Rigney: 37:38
Well, I believe it’s a little more. They have to be in a place that they’re lawfully allowed to be.
Jake Rigney: 37:43
Yeah.
Teri Muehlhausen: 37:43
So you can be pretty far away and could you like even you can be far enough away and look right?
Jake Rigney: 37:53
Yeah, that’s an interesting question, right? If you if you flew the drone straight up over the public alley you’re standing in, you would still be in public airspace. But I don’t think you’re allowed to do that.
Kassi Rigney: 38:04
I think that’s Well, and make it even closer, you could have a pole cam with really good that is high enough to look into someone’s. They’re not supposed to be looking, peeking through windows, peeking over fences.
Jake Rigney: 38:18
Yeah, and I don’t think they’re allowed to use, you know, say the the power line elevator booth lift thing. Right. To to look over a fence that they’re not supposed to be, you know, that you can’t look over standing on the alley.
Kassi Rigney: 38:30
Well, but then again, I guess if you’re you’re in a high building and someone’s naked in their backyard because it’s public nudity, right? And if you know all the people in public up on floors three and above can see you naked in your backyard.
Jake Rigney: 38:48
Yeah, but I mean, high up in a building is different, right? Because you know that there’s going to be people up there in the building that can see down into the yard. Well, so you’re you don’t really have a reasonable expectation of privacy there because you know that people can see. Whereas if you have a real fenced-in backyard with no big building next to you, you still have a reasonable expectation of privacy in your backyard.
Kassi Rigney: 39:13
And do you think that they would apply the same logic to the pole cam? You know that there’s a public camera right here.
Jake Rigney: 39:21
I don’t know. Uh I don’t I mean, I guess it’s possible, but that would be an interesting one. I I’ve never I haven’t seen the police try to do that.
Kassi Rigney: 39:31
I’m probably giving them ideas now.
Jake Rigney: 39:33
I you know, I worry about that sometimes. I worry because I have like all sorts of ideas of stuff I would do if I was a cop, right? That they don’t even think of. And I am not gonna tell you what any of them are because I’m afraid one of them will listen and be like, that’s a good point. We can pull over everyone. And I’m not trying to make us more of a police state than we already are. And spoiler alert, we are.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:00
All right, Kassi, are you up? Sure. Your next rule is you this one’s a good one for you. You must begin answering within three seconds or you lose your turn.
Kassi Rigney: 40:12
I’ll lose. Um, it’s already done now. Go ahead. I was gonna tell you, you need to give me a whole break, and you just need to cut out the dead space ahead because I can’t come up with any answers for you.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:24
I got I I think you get this one. All right. Do you have to answer the door when the police knock on it?
Kassi Rigney: 40:30
No.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:32
You did it.
Jake Rigney: 40:33
Yeah, one second. Yep.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:36
Nice.
Kassi Rigney: 40:37
Well, that was just that was the easiest one. Doesn’t need an explanation.
Jake Rigney: 40:41
Now she’s complaining, but it’s too easy, Teri.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:45
I can’t please everyone here. Okay, Jake.
Jake Rigney: 40:50
What?
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:51
Your house rule is.
Jake Rigney: 40:52
Oh, there’s another one.
Teri Muehlhausen: 40:53
Yes. Well, we have we have two more. Okay. Okay. You have to answer like a politician.
Jake Rigney: 40:59
What’s the score?
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:00
You got two and you got two.
Jake Rigney: 41:01
Oh, it’s two to two.
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:02
Yep.
Jake Rigney: 41:03
Tiebreaker.
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:04
It is.
Kassi Rigney: 41:04
You gave me you I that first one counted. I thought not only did it it was a poor form, but I uh I had a long explanation.
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:13
She’s the she’s the point giver.
Kassi Rigney: 41:15
Okay.
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:16
So you have to answer like a politician, and that’s answering without actually committing to an answer.
Jake Rigney: 41:22
Okay.
Teri Muehlhausen: 41:24
If someone runs from the police, but they never get caught, can they still be charged with resisting law enforcement?
Jake Rigney: 41:33
I’m not prepared at this point with this limited information to tell you um what could or couldn’t happen. I mean, look, I’m not a f I’m not I can’t see the future, right? What I can tell you is that right now I am committed to providing you the best possible information that I can come up with at any given time. And that’s always gonna be my commitment. You will never stop me from that commitment. My opponent will never stop me from doing everything I can to provide you the best information when I have it. And when that time comes, believe me, Teri, I will be in touch and I will let you know.
Teri Muehlhausen: 42:14
Thank you, thank you. That’s nice. That was good. Are you gonna run for office?
Jake Rigney: 42:21
No, no, you needed to add some pandering to the police uh union in there as well. Yeah, and I should have been like, Teri, that is such a good question. Sorry.
Teri Muehlhausen: 42:36
All right, that’s enough legal education for one day. We’re gonna take a short break, and when we come back, we’re heading to Florida.
Man’s voice: 42:45
Today’s update on Florida Man is brought to you by the sweet release of death. Aren’t you tired of this bullshit yet? Is there any real hope? Even if God is real, do you really think he’s up there thinking, yep, this is just how I planned it? Eight rich dudes and eight billion people who can’t afford a measles vaccine, but also can’t afford to miss work by catching the measles. Perfect. Just what I wanted. No, of course not. If you’re just tired of all this shit, perhaps you should embrace the sweet release of death. Here’s one of our happy customers.
Happy customer’s voice: 43:26
I tried the sweet release of death last week. I won’t get to see my daughter anymore, but at least I don’t have to watch my life savings evaporate because some rich asshole is way into young hot Asian chicks.
Man’s voice: 43:39
Try the sweet release of death today. Or tomorrow. Tomorrow is also fine. Anytime really is fine. We’ll be waiting.
Teri Muehlhausen: 43:52
Alright, welcome back, and it’s time to see what’s happening in Florida. So we have local 10 reports that a night. year old Florida man was arrested, so we’ll call him baby Florida man. Florida teen.
Jake Rigney: 44:08
He’s uh he’s he’s about to graduate to Florida man.
Teri Muehlhausen: 44:11
He was arrested in connection with a theft of a two hundred and ten thousand dollar Porsche from a mansion in Miami Dade County. Uh-huh okay this story has everything it has a luxury sports car thousands of dollars of shoes a police chase two mail trucks and one very unfortunate condition let’s start with the Porsche
Jake Rigney: 44:35
Is is the condition dwarfism no but if that this doesn’t have helped out that’s the if this doesn’t have a dwarf in it then it doesn’t have everything that’s that’s true but
Teri Muehlhausen: 44:46
that might have helped out okay so according to investigators on October 24th a group of at least four Florida people pulled up to a multi-million dollar home in Miami Dade County horse country neighborhood that’s a that’s a mouthful that’s a neighborhood horse country horse country neighborhood yeah they arrived in a Mercedes Benz because apparently when you’re planning to steal a Porsche you have to arrive looking somewhat successful right I mean it I guess that depends on the plan.
Kassi Rigney: 45:25
Have you ever seen a jewelry heist movie ought to go into the jewelry store address to the nines
Jake Rigney: 45:32
Yeah I don’t know a lot of them pull maintenance right um the the bank robbery movies they always come in looking like they’re maintenance men right so that nobody looks at them twice until
Kassi Rigney: 45:44
I guess the point is the same look like you belong one way or another.
Jake Rigney: 45:48
Yeah that’s true.
Kassi Rigney: 45:49
You you belong there you’re not out of place. Right.
Teri Muehlhausen: 45:53
Now investigators say the group broke into a Cadillac escalade parked outside the home’s fenced area then one of the suspects jumped over the fence and got into the Porsche and drove away and that Porsche was not empty. It had seven pairs of shoes reportedly worth four thousand two hundred dollars like what kind of shoes are these?
Kassi Rigney: 46:16
Well you you must not know shoes because uh there are plenty of shoes that one pair will cost that much
Teri Muehlhausen: 46:23
Ted bottom shoes right
Jake Rigney: 46:25
Yeah I mean there are vintage Nikes that sell for hundreds if not thousands of dollars.
Teri Muehlhausen: 46:30
But let’s say that that happened in Indiana these people stole this portion with all those shoes what kind of chargers are we looking at?
Jake Rigney: 46:38
Uh it’s theft and auto theft the theft would be a level six felony because the shoes are worth more than four you know more than seven hundred and fifty dollars and the car is uh it’s just regular auto theft they don’t have in Indiana they don’t have like Grand Theft Auto and all that it’s just auto theft and then if you have a prior it gets enhanced. You don’t think because of the value of the car it would be up to a five oh you know that’s interesting I didn’t think about that yeah did we cover how much is the Porsche worth 21000 is what she said. Yeah I think that does get it over the level to a level five over the dollar number. I forget what the dollar number is is it a hundred thousand dollars
Kassi Rigney: 47:22
I think it’s seven hundred and fifty to a hundred and fifty thousand
Jake Rigney: 47:26
You mean seventy five thousand to a hundred and fifty thousand
Kassi Rigney: 47:30
What’s the the bottom is seven fifty to
Jake Rigney: 47:33
That’s right the the level six felony is seven hundred and fifty dollars at the bottom and then I don’t remember what the top is it’s
Kassi Rigney: 47:40
Either a hundred or a hundred and fifty and then I thought over that.
Jake Rigney: 47:42
Okay.
Teri Muehlhausen: 47:44
Yeah so one of these four men that we have that baby Florida man he this was not his first encounter with the law back in January of this year please say that baby Florida man was driving a rented Kia when officers attempted to pull him over but he did not stop he’s Florida man he took off and he drove through somebody’s front yard and crashed into a US Postal Service mail truck. Then him him and his passenger
Jake Rigney: 48:16
Hold on I’m laughing and I’m not laughing because that’s funny. It’s actually very dangerous and I I don’t encourage people to do that right but I’m laughing because like mailman’s got a story right yeah he’s like man I was just delivering the mail today just like every other day you know how it is envelope hole envelope slot envelope mailbox envelope mailbox crash next thing I know some dude running from the cops crashes into my car I would suck.
Kassi Rigney: 48:47
See I thought it was gonna get really exciting you say Kia the car a police chase and I’m thinking oh my goodness what kind of masterful driver is this you can get out of the you you escape from the police in a Kia
Jake Rigney: 49:00
Getting getting more than a hundred feet away from the cops in a Kia is an achievement they’re not known for being you know high-end cars that that have excellent acceleration and cornering anyway yeah Kia.
Teri Muehlhausen: 49:18
Yeah Kia crashed into mail truck I was gonna I was gonna say baby driver yeah remember baby driver oh yeah what so what does Florida man and his passenger do? Well they run they run to another mail truck and hide in it and attempt to call an Uber to come pick them up
Jake Rigney: 49:40
I mean they’re not gonna get away in the postal truck so
Teri Muehlhausen: 49:43
No but the the cops ended up finding them before their their Uber picked them up.
Jake Rigney: 49:49
I’m all about the other people like so then the Uber driver pulls up right well and the Uber driver’s gotta be careful because if the people do anything to indicate that they’re fleeing from the police and he the driver accepts the ride well he’s fleeing from the police now too he’s assisting a criminal that’s true yeah he’s an accomplice so he would actually be committing the same crime um that they are which is fleeing from the police at that point. Yeah so like so now the Uber driver pulls up right and all he sees is like 30 cop cars right and he’s like is is uh is is Steve here and they’re like Steve’s not gonna be with you today thank thank you cancel
Teri Muehlhausen: 50:32
A UPS truck on fire in the background
Jake Rigney: 50:37
Tough day for the service uh industry.
Teri Muehlhausen: 50:39
The investigators had a very easy time of finding this Porsche because when baby Florida man was caught up in this Kia Uber stuff he ended up getting put on house rest and he had an ankle monitor on him and with that ankle monitor on him he thought it would be a great idea to go steal a Porsche.
Jake Rigney: 51:06
You know I I I think that you thought this would surprise me but I I had a case like that when I was a prosecutor. I had an attempted murder case where the the defendant was wearing his home detention ankle monitor at the strip club that he was most certainly not allowed to go to and then shot a guy.
Teri Muehlhausen: 51:32
Does he have dementia like why like?
Jake Rigney: 51:34
No.
Kassi Rigney: 51:35
Like we talked about these are not decisions m based on you know rational this is not rational decision making
Teri Muehlhausen: 51:42
They’re not like that’s not rational.
Jake Rigney: 51:45
Stop stop trying to apply reason to it Teri.
Teri Muehlhausen: 51:47
Yeah I need I need to stop.
Jake Rigney: 51:49
It’s not it won’t make sense you will you’ll break your brain.
Teri Muehlhausen: 51:52
Yeah it might be broken because that’s all I have from the desk.
Jake Rigney: 51:56
Well thank you Teri and uh thank you dear listeners for listening to another episode of Tales from the Brown Desk. Please remember while we may discuss legal issues and provide information regarding the law to our listeners we do not intend to create an attorney client relationship with any listener. We’re just trying and probably failing to be funny. If you have a legal issue our advice may not be applicable to it please consult with an attorney you have hired to review your legal situation before you attempt to apply anything we have said to your case or worse yet before you try to go pro se and represent yourself because you heard things we said on here. Keep in mind we’ve said repeatedly trying to represent yourself is an awful idea. Do not complain us later when it does not go well when you misapply the advice we have provided here. Tales from the Brown Desk is produced by Rickney Law and Teri Muehlhausen. If you want to ask a listener question email Teri at Teri @tales from the Brown Desk.com and entitle your email Podcast Question and we’ll read it on our next podcast. If we answer it you can be certain you will be dissatisfied BuzzSprout says this episode will get 40 downloads that’s a drop in listeners we peaked last month we are hemorrhaging listeners like the Titanic hemorrhaged buoyancy after it’s split in half sorry Teri we are letting you down I don’t know why uh you should probably put all the outtakes in um the podcast this week maybe that’ll make people uh find us more interesting I don’t know our newest faraway listener is from La Hugue in Cebu City in the Philippines I have probably horribly butchered all the names I just said except for the Philippines every time I think of the Philippines I think of the story of plucky underdog rebels fighting to free themselves from the distant rule of a colonial government aligned with that country’s business interests while refusing to give the colony and their colonists representation in the government. Does that sound familiar Teri?
Teri Muehlhausen: 54:19
A little bit
Jake Rigney: 54:19
It does. Right that’s the US revolution right no that’s not what I’m talking about. After the media ginned up a fake justification to fight a war against Spain in the 1890s Spain gave us the Philippines Guam and Puerto Rico for the low low price of 20 million US dollars and also so that we would stop beating their ass the Philippines were already in a revolution they were revolting against their Spanish oppressors and we did not give them their independence after we defeated Spain and Spain sold them to us uh so the Philippines continued their revolution against their new oppressors the United States so we went halfway around the world and crushed their revolution likely causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of native Filipinos and probably about 4500 Americans who fought in the war and died. That’s what we do why did we do this rubber tin and sugar were very valuable commodities back then and the Philippines had a bunch of it so the next time you hear our American origin story about us hard scrabble Americans fighting for freedom against a tyrannical government who wouldn’t give us any representation remember it took us about 125 years and 25 presidents to sacrifice those ideals at the altar of money and power and ask yourself have we ever stopped the attorneys at Rickney Law do not comment on their current pending cases. Nothing we have said in this podcast is a comment on a case we are currently working on even if you are Jensen Huang or Emilio Aguinaldo, the leader of the Philippine Revolution take care.
Teri Muehlhausen: 56:26
Bye.
Kassi Rigney: 56:27
Bye.